Analysis & Opinions - Foreign Policy

Why We Failed to Win a Decisive Victory in Afghanistan

| March 2, 2015

Shifting political allegiances, not smashing enemies, should have been the goal. And that holds true for the campaign against the Islamic State as well.

There's been a great debate over on Tom Ricks's Best Defense blog in response to Jim Gourley's question in relation to the Afghanistan campaign: "Why did we fail to render our enemies — those people who actively participated in open hostility against our forces — powerless?" Perhaps not surprisingly, many of the responses have taken the view that we have, indeed, lost in Afghanistan.

I take issue, however, with the starting assumption that "rendering our enemies powerless" should be the standard by which we evaluate the success of military action in Afghanistan, or lack thereof. I think the assumption clouds the analysis of both of Afghanistan and the conflict against so called Islamic State....

Continue reading (log in may be required): http://foreignpolicy.com/2015/03/02/why-the-war-in-afghanistan-was-lost-from-the-start-coin-taliban/

For more information on this publication: Belfer Communications Office
For Academic Citation: Simpson, Emile.“Why We Failed to Win a Decisive Victory in Afghanistan.” Foreign Policy, March 2, 2015.

The Author

Recommended
In the Spotlight
RSS
While offsets are imperfect, they may be necessary to reach ambitious short-term environmental goals.
More on Energy
Danielle F. Jung and Dara Kay Cohen argue that lynching emerges when neither the state nor its challengers have a monopoly over legitimate authority.
More on International Security
Western models partly inspired the creation of Special Operation Command and Military Police and the development of private military companies.
More from Russia Matters
Most Viewed

Tags